Upcoming releases

My Problematic Fave: Tom King

It seems like no industry or hobby is free of creators and personalities that are varying degrees of problematic. I do find these levels of ick interesting, not as some kind of tier list, but to examine what some people can forgive, play down or even flatly deny, and what things can’t be ignored.

It’s easy to think that comic books, as a creative and progressive industry, might not be so bad, but we had comics-gate, and industry professionals thinking it was very wrong of Batman to give fascists compound fractures, so we’re not immune. Then there’s the high-profile sex pests, like Ellis, and the even more appalling actions (allegedly) of Gaiman. And we see they have their defenders, and companies willing to keep them in work, because we live in a patriarchal capitalist hellscape.

But, we’re not talking about the far more click worthy stories like this, we’re going to be talking about Tom King, and his seeming lack of regret about his time working for the CIA.

Better people than me can give you deep dives into what he got up to, what his level of involvement was, and whether or not he really should apologise and try to make amends for what he did. I am mostly here to talk about my own thoughts on him, and why I have yet to go so far as to cancel him in store, in the way I have done for the two other people named above.

You see, I love his stuff (mostly, but I don’t have to get into why Heroes in Crisis or Danger Street just didn’t work for me), and will absolutely stand by the fact that he is a killer writer with one hell of a body of work to back up this claim. If you’re reading this, you probably know about his work on Batman and Vision, but his Mister Miracle brought me to tears, and Human Target was a thorough delight. I’m also really loving his run on Wonder Woman, and it’s elements of that book that made me want to get some thoughts down.

You see, we can talk about separating art from artist, and again, there are people out there who cover this topic in far depth than I ever could, but for me, this discussion comes down to whether or not the art is foundational to the harm that was carried out.

I could go on about a certain TERF-ass wizarding world right now, but honestly, if you don’t get why she’s a piece of shit who should absolutely be boycotted in every way imaginable, it’s weird you’re here at all. Keeping it comic book and going back to the aforementioned predators, yes, I think the work is worth talking about when it comes to harm carried out.

Ellis used his position of power, and he totally had one, no matter how much he downplays it, on his forum, which was a huge deal back in the day. Hell, I was on that forum and even posted a few times! The huge amount of work he put out gave him that cultural cache, especially as it was progressive work for the time, calling out patriarchal power structures and being pretty anticapitalist through a futurist lens. A lot of people read things like that, and if they agree with the politics, like I did, would easily come to the conclusion that he was one of the “good ones”.

Gaiman, likewise, had a persona that came through in his writing, and he had even more power, and since I do tend to believe women, it’s safe to say he used that power to atrocious affect, and as such, him and his entire body of work get in the damned sea. I loved a lot of his stuff, but if it was ever used to whitewash his image as a predator, then yeah, we need to say a big no to his stuff still being read and made into TV shows.

And now we come to King. If you’ve read enough of his stuff, you could very easily come to the conclusion that he’s a changed man. Stange Adventure straight up called out the kind of imperialistic thinking that seems to dominate a huge amount of US foreign policy, no doubt inherited from its European roots – the British were great at this kind of stuff, and that’s a very bad thing – and Animal Pound was an obvious critique of the current US Cheeto in Chief.

None of that means he isn’t the man who joined the CIA and undertook actions in Afghanistan though, it just means he’s able to look at some big issues and turn them into comic books that appeal to an audience. Not that I’m saying he’s some kind of uber MAGA fascist or anything. Based on what I have read that he’s produced, and how consistent he is in punching up at those in power, and the structures themselves, it is my opinion that he is not a figure beyond redemption, and I’m glad he’s creating art.

The thing is though; I still can’t shake the fact that he is still kind of problematic. Not only has he not apologised for his role in the CIA – as far as I know – but in his Wonder Woman comic run, we can see some imperialistic, right-wing ideas. True, he spends most of the run with an obvious patriarchal bad guy and even gets into the idea that femme people can support such an institution, providing they get to bask in the reflected power for as long as they’re useful, but he does also send Diana into a foreign state, with the ostensible mission of rescuing people, but actually ends up destabilising the region by attacking its leader.

I’m not saying Mouse Man isn’t a despot within the story King’s creating, but an awful lot of effort goes into selling the idea that all enemies of the US are equally, if not even more despotic than this obvious comic book villain, and the CIA  – and FBI for that matter – are groups that push that kind of messaging to the public, to justify going in to rescue people. Won’t someone think of the children?

In recent years, the Worst President Ever has muddied the water by declaring almost every other country a third world hellscape, and the people who live in those countries get labelled the worst kind of criminal scum, which means the justifications have changed from doing good in these countries to protecting the motherland, but that doesn’t erase the history of regime change and how it was carried out and justified by the US under various administrations.

For most of the rest of his run on Wonder Woman though, King has been far more comfortable in progressive headspace, and it’s only by digging really deep and supposing a whole bunch of stuff that we see more of this kind of ideology. In the book Diane is the hero, and the Amazonians are badly treated by a United States that fears the different, strange, unusual, and uncontrollable. This feeds into lots more writing done by other scribes who have had a chance to write for Wonder Woman, but there is a subtle difference.

in King’s DC world, the US is run by a secret conspiracy lathered overlord, someone with the kind of inherited wealth and power that the entire constitution is set up to prevent. You know, “no kings”. It’s not unusual for superhero books to be written this way, so as not to bring don the ire of current leaders, but the rest of the structures and institutions of the DC version of the US, as written by King, seems very close indeed to how the I, as an outsider, see the actual country.

Having a figurehead so unlikely to actually exist, so deplorable as to be only possible in a fictitious world, does give me pause, and makes me think King is happier blaming a fictional oligarch instead of looking more deeply at the institutional problems that plague the very real United States of America. This might be a stretch though, and me looking for things just to confirm the feelings I have about someone who worked for the CIA, and I am happy to admit I am partial to overthinking things. Still, if I can see things like this, I might not be wrong.

The biggest thing for me though is the intent, and whether his art supports, creates, or encourages harm, and I really don’t think it does. Everything written above is an interpretation, and all falls within the framework of a comic book set in a universe of gods and super-heroes. He’s allowed to have a worldview different than mine, and if that sneaks into books that condemn homophobia and imperialism, that champion women’s rights and tearing down patriarchy, I think I’ll cope.

All this means, as much as I will keep calling King one of my faves, he’s not quite shaken off the “problematic” label just yet. I think there’s room, and because of how overtly progressive so much of his work is, I think I can personally justify continuing to support him. The Mouse Man arc came close to pushing me over that line though, and I wouldn’t judge anyone who saw it as the tipping point…

Join the conversation